The members watch the five Oscar-nominated movies during one week. After each one, each member goes home and writes their review on the blog for the others to read. After all five of the movies have been watched and reviewed, the members get together and vote. Each member explains which movie gets their vote and why against the other films, and the votes are tallied and the winner for that year is posted in the blog later that night.
GEMMA - 2003 - Chicago - The Hours - Gangs of New York - The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - The Pianist
MATT - 2005 - Crash - Brokeback Mountain - Munich - Good Night and Good Luck - Capote
ALLIE - 1995 - Forrest Gump - The Shawshank Redemption - Pulp Fiction - Four Weddings and a Funeral - Quiz Show
WALTER - 1976 - One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest - Dog Day Afternoon - Nashville - Jaws - Barry Lyndon
BEN - 1981 - Ordinary People - Raging Bull - The Elephant Man - Coal Miner's Daughter - Tess